blog backdrop

Saturday 27 February 2016

The Childminder/Nursery/Preschool/Nanny/Au Pair debate:Which is right for you and your child?



So its reached that time when you have to go back to work after a nice maternity leave with your child as these days very few of us have the luxury of staying home even if we want too.  The continuous rise of living vs the cost of childcare.  Is it worth it???

I'm very pro for women and men working and not because it pays my salary!!! This is the year 2016 and its a very old fashioned view to expect women to be the one to stay at home.  Lots of my friends are starting to have children and with a niece and nephew within both sides of the family my siblings/in law siblings also have to face this dilemma.   Now I am not a parent and I never claim to know it all but having worked in nurseries and as a nanny for a long time I can give some pros and cons to different forms of childcare.

Nursery/Preschools

 I was having this conversation with my sister in law recently who will be returning to work in the later half of the year.  She has a very good career but will be going back part time to start with so she can still have some time with my nephew.  When she and my brother in law are at work my nephew will be in a nursery.

This leads into the consideration of nurseries in the debate.  By no means are they cheap, for under two year old children the average price for a fulltime place across the country is £1000 a month (5 days a week roughly 7.30am-6pm).  This is a lot of money and for many people will take up a good proportion of a household income.

Preschools tend to operate term time only and school hours but your child has to be  over 2 1/2 years old.  If these hours suit you and your family they can be great as they can give you a lot of  the same perks of a nursery.  Preschools tend to now be attached to primary schools so can be a great way transitioning into your chosen primary school.

Pros:

  • Socialisation- Your child will be on a ratio of one adult to three children (0-2years), one adult to four children (2-3 years) or one adult to eight children (3+ years).  They will learn not to have one to one adult attention which will teach them important life skills and prepare them for school.
  • Opening hours- a standard nursery will be open all year round for full days which will suit most jobs.
  • When your child turns three you are entitled to 15 free hours a week 38 weeks a hour in a registered provider
  • Preschools are cheaper in cost

Cons:

  • Policy's on illness-  These may be quite rigid when it comes to inclusion from nursery depending on the type of illness but from a professional perspective it is hard to give your poorly child the attention they require when you have other children to care for.
  • You will still have to pay for absences from nursery!- This can seem unfair but nurseries are businesses and would lose money if they allowed you just to take your child out and expect not to pay for it.
  • Preschools are restricted in opening hours and starting age of children

How to research:

  • Internet searching
  • Recommendations

Childminders

I have a very good friend who is a childminder who used to be my boss and she has such a lovely set up in her home and a gorgeous playroom and big garden.  I'm never saying never but I personally do not have the space in my house to facitate it for one and second at this point of my life do not really feel the urge to run my own business.  Never less I think the option of a childminder is absolutely great and another sister in law is considering a childminder for my niece to enable her to work more hours.  My niece at 2 years old is a very socialable little girl and I really think she will excel in this kind of environment.

Pros:

  • When your child turns three you are entitled to 15 free hours a week 38 weeks a hour
  • Pay with childcare vouchers as all childminders are registered with OFSTED
  • Degree of flexibility-long hours available
  • Highly qualified
  • Regularly inspected by OFSTED as they have to be registered
  • Socialisation with other children

Cons:

  • Not exclusive for one family and have set policies and procedures
  • Cant guarantee backup childcare if they are ill or have holiday

How to research:

  • Internet search for ofsted registered childminders in your postcode
  • websites such as gov.uk or childcare.co.uk.
  • reccomendations


Nannies/Au Pairs

Nannies are without a doubt the most expensive option for your childcare.  The luxury of having the individual attention for your children does come unfortunately at a cost.  Nowadays there are ways around making the cost less by Nanny Shares with other families in your area in which you would split the cost.  Au Pairs  can make this option also more affordable as they come and live in your house and your provide them with food etc and a small amount of pocket money weekly.  Ultimately Nannies and Au Pairs do the same type of work but hiring an Au Pair will mean more restrictions as they often are coming to the country to learn your language, experience a new culture, studying etc.

Pros:

  • More flexibility- good if parents travel for work and are away from the home or work irregular hours.  You can also have live in/live out/part time/fulltime nannies.
  • Enables children to be in their home environment or pursue their interests for example afterschool activities.
  • Close relationships- If you get it right the relationship between a nanny/au pair and the family they work for can be great.  I have found that you learn so much more about a child seeing them in their home environment and its very special to be welcomed in to a family.
  • Nannies are regulated to have certain qualifications. If you pay to have your nanny ofsted registered you can use childcare vouchers as a method to pay their salary.

Cons:

  • Expensive (Nannies)
  • Can be a pain if your nanny is ill so a backup plan needs to be considered
  • Au Pairs are restricted by working hours so you would need to check the small print on hiring one.
  • Au Pairs are short term solutions generally a year so do not always provide consistency for your children.

How to research:

I recommend to all parents looking for a nanny/au pair to go through a local agency.  This is how I got my current position and the process is made easier for the nanny and the family.  The agencies will vet the nanny prior to even sending them on an interview so you will have been checked for references, criminal checks, qualifications.  They do obviously charge you a fee for doing this but I really think if you way it up it takes the hassle and the worry away from you.

Another good platform for looking for these can be Childcare.co.uk in which you can register and search for childcare that you need near to you.

Hope this has given some food for thought and would love some feedback

Nanny Bicester xx

Twitter-@nannybicester

No comments:

Post a Comment